Monday, November 21, 2011

Lesson Plan Ideas

Look at a current event issue like the occupy wall street protest and look a across media outlets to see how they are being labeled, and look at people and find out about their views, where they get their news, how they feel about other issues, where if you feel one way about occupy wall street does that mean you feel another way about a bunch of other issues.

Buckingham ch.5 Classroom Strategies

Look at 6 teaching techniques
  • existing knowledge for that which needs to be taught
  1. Textual Analysis
    • focuses in great detail on a single text, with close attentino to detail and rigorous questioning
    • students need to provide evidence for their views
    • take something famililar and look very close at it
    • analyze visual and audio text like litarature
    • HOW
      • semiotics, 3 stages
      • Description-identify all they can hear and see
        • close eyes and just listen
        • close ear and just wach
      • Meaning-what does text remind you of
        • commutation, how would the interpretation change if an element was changed, if a different character or music were used
      • Judgments-what values and claims is the ad arguing
        • is the argument effective or did it fail and how
    • meanings are not always universal
    • goal is not agreement but of systematic and rigorous analysis
    • it needs to be applied to real texts in real contexts, and explored in practical ways
  2. Contextual Analysis
    • textual analysis removes text from context-close attetnion to context enables usto understand the connections between media language and production and audience
    • technique-focus on a piece of text you would usually ignore***
      •  Opening scene of a tv show cna show a lot of the assumptions made by producers about their audience-this is good when used to contrast say two different films potraying the same idea in different ways, students can look to see who produced and disributed it, or how two tv shows about the same thing are aimed at two different audiences**
    • How was a text marketed and distrubted to audiences.
      • looking at tv listings, magazines, ads, promotional web sites,
      • evaluate the material looking at the claims and methods used to promote it
      • how is one film marketed in two different countries
    • How was the text recieved
      • find data on tv ratings, box office sales, and reviews
      • was the advertising effective at reaching its audience
      • also think how this information is gathered
    • Music industry
      • students begin to study cd covers, poster, and ads, than move on to look at other merchandising
      • a band seeking to widen its audience might show signs of this on their album covers from one album to the next
      • shows that marketing and ormotino are crusiall impotant aspects of the wasy in which texts find audiences.
      • yet to show it is not a conspiracy to brian wash audience we must also look at failde marketing and promotional compaigns
  3. Case Studies
    • in depth research into a media topic
    • simplist, focuses on the production, marketing and consumption of a particular text.
      • launch of something new, film, tv show, magazine
    • cross media investigation of an issue
      • look at say animals in advertising-or the media coverage of a particular event
    • investigating media audiences
      • develop and administer questionairres looking at patterns of media use
      • investigate a single media compnay
    • so if you were to take a tv for example, you
      • watch the show
      • analyze parts of the show
      • look at how other media cover the show-tv-magazines-internet
      • how does the tv show itself promote and publicise the show
      • students will develop research skills
      • might be easy to find information but harder to judge its authenticity

Sunday, November 20, 2011

Buckingham Chaptor 4 Defining the Field

  • q4 key concep
    • production
    • language
    • representation
    • audience
  • Production
    • most media are produced by groups for commercial profit-what economic interests are at stake-how to profit off that-global scale, 
    • global vs local relationship
    • you can look at case studies, of lage companies, 
    • or compare large companies to small companies
    • have students find who owns their favorite publications
    • the students will confront all these questions and more if they are tasked with making their own product
  • Language
    • each media has its own language to create meanin
    • paradigmatic (selecting from a range of possible elements) vs syntagmatic (putting the elements together in a sequence)
    • it involved making the familiar strange by looking in detail how text are composed and put together, for ex. you can physically deconstruct an image or breaking it down to its component parts
    • comparison-can identify shared conventions, and patterns
    • production also more insight than just studying. 
  • Representation
    •  production involves selecting and combining incidents, combining events into stories, and creating characters.
    • bound to be biased yet we bring our own biased into interpreting it
    • we can still learn something even when we know it is fantasy
    • students can easily find the biased of a newspaper, by looking at the editorial section but it is harder to see that biased in the selection of stories and treatment, in words and images
      • comparison between different newspapers is a good technique**
    • stereotyping-
    • production-can help understanding if students are asked to produce a story about a familiar event aimed at two different audiences
  • Audiences
    • seen as gullible and easily influenced, especially kids-yet this is not what research shows
    • hard to show how somethings become popular and some dont
    • studying adiences means
      • looking at how they are targeted and measured
      • looking at how media are circulated and distributed
      • looking at the different ways social groups and individuals, use, interpret, and respond to media
    • a study of how the media industries operate-for example, how are telivision audiences and newspaper readers measured, and how is this used for advertising rates
    • how are different social groups reached, by magazine covers for ex. 
    • how are fans cultivated
    • students should keep media diaries-compare with peers
    • record use of media in household-compare with peers
  • Concepts in Practice
    • each concepts is a point of entry into media education that evokes the others. 
    • can be applied to both creative activities(photographing) and analytical (studying advertising)
  • Example 1 Teaching the simpsons
    • using a tv programm as a case study
    • Activities;
      • 1. Watch title sequence closely, noting key elements. Move into group discussion. Than have student write up wha they learned, how the intro sets up expectations
      • 2.Student given history of family situation comedy. They

  • Aims
    • most of the work is deductive rather than inductive .
    • its about students reaching their own conclusions instead of pointing them to one direction
  • Curriculum Planning
    • touch on all four concepts, some more than others, than unify them in a final project
    • anyone of the concepts surves as a way into the others
  • Pedegogy
    • individual, group, and whole class work
    • all units start with assumption that the student has knowledge they bring to the table
    • bu there is knowlegde the student does not have

Sunday, November 13, 2011

Weaver Chaptor 5

  • Teacher education does not focus on popular culture
  • Given time cultural studies will be as big in education as literature
  • Paul Willis- study on working class males in england-How do they formulate their own culture and resist the dominant culture? He found males saw school as one of the major inst. that reproduced the status quo. even though the men realized this, by rebelling, they gave the ruling class exactly what they wanted. 
  • Leslie Roman and Linda Christian-Smith study-established the roots of cultural studies in education-Becoming Feminine-an alternative to male dominated discourse-offered their own interpretation of cultural studies that did not subdue women
  • Henry Giroux, combined a stinging criticism of the corporate influence on popular culture tastes while offering a distinct alternative to corporate popular culture that fosters the development of democratic ideals in schools and pop culture. 
    • combined critique and hope
    • views people as objects, who do not interact with pop culture, but who are manipulated
  • Childhood Studies;
    • reject ideas that children grow in progressive stages
    • studies on the myriad of ways corporations now shape the identities and affective tastes of young people. corporate ethos has shaped and infected the thinking of young people
    • Shirly Steinberg Joe Kincheloes work Kindercutlure-what does it mean to grow up in a postmodern, hyper-mediated, unrelenting corporatized world. The corporatizing of children undermind everything the parents value. 
      • parents no longer raise kids alone, but along with nintendo, mcdonalds and tv.
      • the coproration promises the kids the world, the parents have to tell the kids they cant have it. 
    • Gaile Cannella suggests we should give young people voices in the research and policies they advocate, against the amoral , nihilistic corporate values. 
    • The strongest value instilled by the corporation is the will to consume.  Ones identity is shaped by consumption. corporations use education to sell, and advertise in schools. 
      • kids as young as two can have their tastes shaped, 
      • coporations like to build brand loyalty early. 
    • Consuming Children by Jane Kenway and Elizabeth Bullen-they chart the ways in which young people have been recast as untapped markets and the school curricula is seen as the first peublic relations opport. Taco bell, BK, and Pizza hut and coke have made inroads into schools.
    • Exonn has created an envirnmental curriculum
    • Schools are not innocent in this, they take gifts to save money at the expense of the child
    • They offer action, kids can retake their schools public space, and enter a dialoge
    • cyberflaneur, where kids can interact across states or nations to experience different cultures, to change their attitudes
    • Peter McLaren, sees consumerism as a fomr of predatory cutlure. to counteract the seductiveness of predatory culture mclaren seeks to create a critical pedagogy tha permits students to become actores in history rather than passive conduits. If they dont assert themselves others are ready to define them
  • Media LiteracyPrograms in Schools
    • How do images shape our reality
    • 1.schools should offer students the opportunity to critique multimedia sources so they can see houw imaes construc reality and understand how they can critique images
    • 2.schools should offer media sources as a supplement to written docs.
      • instead of just having them watch a movie and read a book, students should also learn how each medium is different and how each medium presents reality****
    • Robert Rosenstone, leading scholar comparing modern media, tv, with past media, books-
      • film cannot tell the story the same way, its too different
      • both are not the past, but merely represent the past
      • main point, is that while movies are limited to 2 hours, books have no space limit to tell a story.
      • film makers use techniques to overcome this like
        • condensation-taking numerous historical charectors and condensing them into one, or taking numerous events and condesing them into one event
    • Brian Goldfarb-visual pedagogy-recoginize images bombard our mind everyday-
      • advocates students as media creators-
      • when students interact with images, film ,and video they begin an engagement process.
    • Toby Daspit-believes that popular culture has become a place where students question the world and act as agents in the world in order to change the world
  • Curiculum  Studies
    • most dynamic field in eduction
    • best hope for understanding the relationship betwenen education and popular culture
    • Susan Edgerton-how cultural studies informs how we can rething schol curricula.
    • Peter Applebaums -How can e incorporate he ideas of our students into our curriculum plans.
      • asked elementary school kids how teachers could utilize the story lines of sat morning cartoons in the classroom
      • the teachers struggled
    • Noel Gough -if teachers want to teach science well they should abandon textbooks and use comics, a popular cultural source-text books do not cover the last hundred years like comics do?
    • These new ideas do not always work out, and the prized tenure is sometimes denied.
    • Greg Dimitriadis-studies african american youth in a small midwest urban setting.
      • hip hop provided answers for them , as to why capitalist america showed little interest in their plight as young people growng up in the USA
  • Future of Cultural Studeis
    • scholars will have start acknoledging the impact of pop culture in their research
    • violence on tv does not create violent people, it can fuel the creative faculties of a distubed young person, but focusing onhwat influences the imagination does not address what triggers a person to act violently.
    • a healhty approach would develop a pedagogy that utilizes the power of popuar culture in order to enhance democracy

Sunday, October 30, 2011

Understanding Advertising

  • What identities does the ad produce? 
  • In what way does it construct them? 
  • What is the ideal state and status it suggests us? 
  • What anxieties about oneself can it trigger? 
  • It is also crucial to consider the personalities of actors that present the brand. As Borgerson and Schroeder state it, “pictures of people – models, celebrity endorsers, spokespersons, “average” consumers, managers and employees – make up a large part of marketing imagery” (2005). 
  • Ask yourself, what meanings do the actors bring? 
  • What do they mean to us in their sign systems (film\fashion\sport industry or politics)? 
  • Why do you think they were selected to present the brand you analyze? 

  •  Modern advertising imagery seeks to sell us not just products  but images of ourselves
  • Advertising represents ideal states, causing insecurity about one’s social position \ body \ status or something else.
  • Thus the work of advertisement is not to invent a meaning for No.5, but to translate meaning for it by means of a sign system we already know. It is only because Catherine Deneuve has an ‘image’, a significance in one sign system, that she can be used to create a new system of significance relating to perfumes. If she were not a film star and famous for her chic type of French beauty, if she didn’t mean something to us, the link made between her face and the perfume would be meaningless.
  • Myths;
    • Claude Levi Strauss-all data is arranged according to the universal laws of human thought
    • general scheme for all myths-they are similiar throughout the world
    • Binary opposition, good/bad, black/white
    • each myth has a common special mission, 
    • each myth has a mediator to help bridge binary opposition, life vs. death=zombie, half in both worlds
    • Vladimir Propp-analysed russian folktalkes, developed a typology of 31 narratives structures that are continually repeated in myth. 
    • all adventures of the hero lead him to a new state, a poor man becomes rich, a fool becomes clever. 
    • Many advertisement use this, a product, to overcome a problem. 


Friday, October 28, 2011

MOd 5 vIDeo's

Rich Media Poor Democracy;

  • 3 tiers of corporate media
    • 1.Huge-Viacom-aol.time warner
    • 2.medium-comcast-general electric-new york times
    • 3.small-
  • Journalism, healthy is the cornerstone of democracy, a rigourous acounting of people in power and those that wish to be in power, a way to get the truth the come out, need a wide range of opinions.
  • today the small number of corporate owners goes after profit not democracy-cut spending-increase entertainment
  • we get weaker journalism, easy journalism, covering the queen of england, 
  • political stories will interview a republican and democrat but never try to find out who is telling the truth
  • This leads to problems when we get into war-war coverage journalism was horrible-
  • our journalist seem to be late to most meaningful stories.
What Happened to the news (2)

I follow a lot of current events/news media, especially the internet, because what is on tv is garbage. The ideas and framing of ideas has less to do with informing and initiating and intilectual adult debate based on facts,and more to do with pulling at people heart strings and fear, and belief strings, with hot button  words. I posted this fact on facebook this week about new media, "Well, for one, to our major newspapers, what’s “torture” overseas isn’t always that closer to home. A Harvard study found The New York Times called waterboarding torture 82 percent of the time from 1930 to 2004. After that, when the U.S. became the most famous waterboarder, the Times called it torture 1 percent of the time." 

This goes back to my world view, that the powers that dominate our nation, which own the media, do not benefit by having a smart, thinking, educated public, and media plays a large role in that idea. 

The Myth of Liberal Media
Noam Chomsky makes a great point, the power brokers that run the system do not want any challengers, they conrol the massive from challenging them with propoganda. There is a great book out that I have not read called Whats the Matter with Kansas. The central theme of the book, as I understand it, is to show how political leaders in Kansas were able to get the population of Kansas to vote against their own interest. 
Its like the idea of the estate tax. This was a tax on mega wealth, not on the average man. The goal was to prevent royal dynasty from Europe being built here. As we know royal European dynasties were very powerful and controlled the nation and the people of Europe for many hundreds of years, using many oppressive actions agains the common man. Our country did not want to see these power structures build up and passed on from generation to generation. So we taxed them at death. Today the debate has shifted, and it is framed by the media spin doctors as a death tax, arguing if you die you will be taxed, and we are all equally taxed, but that is not true. This tax effects only a very small percentage of our nation, yet this powerful group was able to sell the idea to the people of this country that it was the worst thing in the world, and that everyone would be effected. So the majority of people voted to end this tax, even though it was not in their interest.

Mickey Mouse, Monopoly

  • What kind of stories are being told
  • how is disney shaping our children
  • disney owns tv, movie production, theme parks, magazines, they wield a powerful place in shaping popular culture
  • How does it impact Democracy?
  • Some of the messages are dangerous, beauty and the beast, where the girl is abused and yelled at but she still loves the beast. 
Reviving Ophelia
  • Teens and girls today are pushing away their parents to find out how to be a women from tv and magazine, and image that shows women being very skinny and sexual
  • As the girsl in the media get skinnier, the women in real life get fatter, why?

Monday, October 24, 2011

Lesson Plan Notes

Show students examples of misleading ways in which data are presented in media, *or in which ideas are presented. John Stewert has a whole show dedicated to this idea, where he mocks tv cable news, especially fox news. There was that one segment where he showed fox  news shows, which make up only two shows on the network had stories like, "people are saying", or "reports are coming out", about issues fox news supports. The thing is that these reports were from fox news channel, more specifically opinion shows on the network, which make up 80% of the shows.

Pointing out language constructs. Thom Hartmann, and David Sirota play this game well, when they talking about framing a debate. Like Obama's health care bill, the opposition republicans tried to use a negative name to make him own it, calling it obama-care. Or Hartmann like to say we do not have an illegal immigrant problem we have an illegal employer problem. Immigrant problem blames the immigrant, the person risking life and limb to come here to make a better life for his family. This is the story everyone in this country can relate to because our ancestors all went through it. Only the bravest came here. The lazy stayed in Europe. But the media, trying to make them seem bad, labels them illegal, which they are.

 But Thom points out they came here for a hundred years and left in the fall after harvest season. And only in the past few decades did they begin to stay because of lax laws on companies hiring them. If no company would hire them through the winter they would return to south american and Latin america like they have for hundreds of years. The business friendly media does not blame the employers, Yet if no one hired these immigrants we would not have an issue.

Another great selling of language is Republicans use of Welfare. When anyone thinks of welfare today they think of lazy, poor people who sit home all day, don't work, and collect a government check. While this is true, they do not milk the system as much as corporate welfare. Take oil companies, back in the 70's when oil was a record low price and oil companies had a hard time making money our government passed subsidies that actually paid them to stay in business. Today when oil prices are record high, and oil company profits are the highest in the world of any corporation, the subsidies are still used. Makes no sense. This one subsidy probably is more than all poor welfare programs.

*Have the students create innacurate messages to gloss over a terrable issue. *

How the message reflects the creator, fox news is owned and operated by a former republican speach writer. Or how movies are created onthe editing floor. where so many differernt movies could be created from teh same film.