Showing posts with label mod1fall2011. Show all posts
Showing posts with label mod1fall2011. Show all posts

Saturday, September 10, 2011

Protection/We are less fragmented

One concept discussed in Chaptor 1 of buckingham was the need to protect children from the dangerous internet and how the new technology is so different it warrents new protection.

I do not like this idea. I think the concept of protecting our youth from bad influences predates any media. Parents probably told their kids 10,000 years ago, during the hunting and gathering times, not to play with certain people who were a bad influence. I think this message, of protection can be found in any age, in the age where the only form of media was the book, and than with the addition of the telivision, and news paper, and now the internet. The struggles and fears we go through as a culture today are the same one's around since forever.


"Because of cost many youth are being left behind, with no access to media, internet,tv, etc. and many social commentators see the world as more fragmented and individualized," *(how can that be with the internet?) 

This is another concept from chaptor one that I disagree with. With the age of the internet people can connect with people form all over the world. The world is so much less fragmented and connected it ridiculous. When Iran began protesting a fews years back after a fraudulent election the Iranian people organized their protests through twitter. The outside world did not have to rely on a corporate dominated view of the events, from fox news or nbc news. These mass market news outlets have a history of producing such a narrow view of events. Instead I was able to hear about the events directly from Iranians on twitter. And I could directly help out. For example the Iranian government was able to cut off twitter acounts from those who had a certain setting on their account, where the local time was iranian time. People all around the world were asked, and began to change this setting to local Iranian time. 


Pop culture is made in a factory.

  • *DEFENSIVENESS; representing a suspicion of the media and popular culture*(popular media is created in a lab). This view sees the media as powerful and negative, and the children that consume it are very vulnurable. Teaching media can empower them.
Growing up I has such an innocent trusting view. In college I became a Political Science student and watched all the 24 hour media channels to gobble up all the knowledge I could. I trusted what they produced, as being honest, and truly fair and balanced, like some networks profess, because I was a patriotic innocent American. It seemed outside my world view that this news outlet would produce propoganda to indoctrinate me into a narrow world view that would benefit a minority group who sought to gain and hold onto more and more power. 

So one day my best friend calls me up, asks me what I think about Israel and they way they are treating the Palestinians. I tell him the fox news talking points, that Israel is a free, honest, humanitarian nation who is subject to terrorist attacks, and so they have no choice, for their own safety, to increase security around the Palestitnian people. My friend told me to check out a website common dreams, I did, and there my perspective on the world changed. There were other perspectives here, views that challenged the world fox news talked about. I was shocked. It was like my first semester in College, at Nassau Community, when I took my first Philosophy class, my perspective on the changed, my way of looking at things changed. 

Needless to say my view on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict changed. Why would a nations 1000 times as strong and powerful, Isreal, act like such a bully to a weak, crippled, people, the Palestinians? How would we as Americans act if Israeli's came to the USA and started populating it and pushing Americans out of the way, than when we get mad and protest they attack us? How could a people like the jews, me being one, leave Europe after all the brutalities of WW2 that they endured and become like torturers and torture the Palestinians? These questons made no sense to me. These questions challenged my moral philosophy. These questions were not even discussed on the news programs that shaped my world view. 
I began to see how corrupt the mass popular news media system was and is. 

Another part of pop culture I wish to challenge is music. In the music industry today it does not seem like popular music is music that filters through the people and becomes popular in a democratic format. Instead I think pop music, and pop culture is created in a factory. Musical talent are found based on voice alone while someone else writes their music, someone else dresses them, they have a publicist to project a certain image to the world. They have promoters who get them played on all the popular tv and radio stations. It is almost forced down our throats. 

Democratizing the classroom for the Digital Native Student

  • *Wider move to DEMOCRATIZE, to buildt connections between the cultures of the school and those of the home and the peer group.  Teachers had starting working with the cultures the students brought to the classroom, instead of imposing the high culture on the students. This was a direct challenge to the elitism of established litarary culture. 
This idea of democratizing the education system was brought up in our last class with the ideas of the Digital Native and Digital Immigrant. Where it was discussed that a new form of education was needed to reach a new type of student, a Digital immigrant.  A student who has grown up immersed in a digital media world. Who's baby sitter is the tv or dvd. This student has an internet ready smart phone by 1st grade. They facebook they twitter, they text photo's. And these students are bored with traditional forms of education that places the teacher in front of the room lecturing and the places the student in a desk taking notes. The Digital Native students want to use the new forms of media in the classroom. They want to bring there cutlure from outside the classroom into the classroom. But the teachers, Digital Immigrants need to catch up with the technology and learn how to do that. 

Chaptor one buckingham notes

-CHAPTOR ONE BUCKINGHAM-
  • Media literacy aims ot develop both critical understanding and active participation. 
  • It is concerned with teaching and learning about the media and not with how to use media to deliver information in the classroom. 
  • kids spend most of their leisure time consuming media
  • The media are the major contemporary means of cultural expression and communication *Research what were past means of cultural expression*
  • The media has replaced the church, family, and school as the major socializing influence in contemporary society
  • It is not all powerrul, it is unavoidable, they provide many of the symbolic resources we use to conduct and interpret our relationships and to define our identity
3 early histories of media in the UK
  1. F.R. Leavis/Denys Thompson wrote the book Cutlure and Envirnment; The training of Critical awareness. They saw media as a corrupting influence. They sought to teach media to encourage students to discriminate and resist, to arm themselves in battle against commercial manipulation. They sought to expose wha tthey saw as crude exploitations and the cheap emotional falsity of popular cutlure, and they took for granted that once exposed it would be condemned.
  2. Britiish Cultural studies of the 50's/60's, Raymend Williams, and Richard Hoggart, began to challenge the distinction between high culture and popular culture. Film became an accepted form of media yet not tv. 
  3. 70's, Screen Theory, Len Masterman. fundamental aim was to reveal how the constructed nature of media texts, and media representations reinforced the ideologies of dominant groups within society. students were to put their pleasures aside to expose the hidden ideologies of the media. 
  • *Wider move to DEMOCRATIZE, to buildt connections between the cultures of the school and those of the home and the peer group.  Teachers had starting working with the cultures the students brought to the classroom, instead of imposing the high culture on the students. This was a direct challenge to the elitism of established litarary culture. (digital native)
  • *DEFENSIVENESS; representing a suspicion of the media and popular culture*(popular media is created in a lab). This view sees the media as powerful and negative, and the children that consume it are very vulnurable. Teaching media can empower them.
  • Media education can be seen as the solution to some social problems, like the idea that violent media creates social violence. 
  • technology makes it harder to protect children from accessing anything they want, and regulation of any kind can restrict participation.
  • The new approach, by young teachers who grow up with the media, and feel more comfortable with it wants to give the youth unlimited access to media, while having tools to make informed decisions. Media eduction changes from protection to preperation.
  • Because of cost many youth are being left behing, with no access to media, internet,tv, etc. and many social commentators see the world as more fragmented and individualized, *(how can that be with the internet?) 
  • So educators can no longer see themselves as legislators, imposing the values and norms of official culture. The best they can hope for is to act as interpreters making available multiple realities and diverse fomrs of perception and knowledge. 

What is media

"The media do not offer a transparent window on the world . they provide channels through which representations of images of the world cna be communicated indirectly. The medai provide us with selective version of the world, rather than direct access to it."


This is a profound statement that I think needs to be made more clear to the masses of media consumers out there. That each time I turn on the telivision to be informed I am only seeing a small sliver of the information that it takes to be informed. I think this is the case under normal conditions yet we do not live under normal conditions. Our media our world has morphed into a world full of conglomorates where a few companies own large quantities of smaller companies. Our world is dominated by monopolies. These monopolies own such a large part of the pie that when they produce media for the world to see they offer a hyper  selective version of the world.

One example of this I read some time ago is the massive company called General Electric. Today they own weapons companies and NBC. So when our country goes to war which they like to do these days with Iraq, Afghanistan, Lybia, and many more that we do not know about, GE makes money producing and selling weapons. At the same time GE owns NBC which is a tv station that produces many news programs, presenting what is going on in the world to American media consumers. But since GE has a direct interest in continuing and increasing the war's we are involved in the media they produce through NBC can change its philosophy to benefit this. Where news media's main goal is to inform the public, NBC can and does alter this goal/ideal show only the good parts of war, and hide the bad.

To me, this is an immoral stance, especially since few know about this connection. I think if more Americans did know about this huge conflict of interest they would watch NBC news programs with a different perspective, one that is much more critical, and much less trusting.