Bill Pelz article, (my) Three principles of effective online pedagogy, starts off with a line that encapsulates his whole article,
“The learner not the teacher is the one in charge of what gets learned. Put the student in charge of their own learning. Be the guide to the side”
This is a cool, interesting philosophy, but one that challenges many assumptions I have of the role of the teacher and student.
Since I have no teaching experience I have to pull from my student experiences. Being a student I never encountered this idea of putting the student in charge of their own learning. I like the classic hierarchy where the teacher is the boss and the student is not. The teachers says jump and the students jumps. Why would I debate this idea? I had not heard of other ideas. I thought this philosophy was the end all be all. I mean, the teacher was well studied so they must know what they are doing so who was I to challenge that.
But this course has challenged that notion. When you look at Bills quote it does not seem that far off, that the learner is in charge of what gets learned. You could have a great teacher but the students just tunes him/her out. The student has the responsibility to enter the classroom, either physically or virtually in a certain stage of consciousness, where he/she is ready to learn, ready to take notes, do readings, and ready to apply theories. If the student goes out to party the night before class and gets no sleep what chance will that student have of absorbing the concepts and ideas taught in that class? If the student takes great notes but decides to never open that notebook outside of class and to never study or ruminate on the ideas he/she learned in class than that student has decided to not partake in the learning process.
So while Bill’s quotes seems evolutionary, and it is when you dig deeper into his article to learn about how he uses this idea in activities, I think most will agree that in the end the student is the decider, on what and how much get’s learned.
That is not to say that the teacher has no role. Bill does not tell his students to go read whatever you want pertaining to the subject we are studying and bring it back to me.
After reading some of what bill does, like having the students lead and moderate the discussions, have the students tutor each other, and having the students approve each other research topics, one might get another assumption, that Bill is lazy and has decided to do as little as possible by giving out his duties to his students. This is also far from the truth.
In the last module I thought and wrote about how much more work creating an online class is and will be be for the instructor, bill has found a great way for the class to run in a large part on its own. Since his directions will be made prior to the start of class during the course itself he will be guiding and evaluating and commenting on the students work, but the other students will be a much larger part of that process than bill is.
I really like what bill is doing, He has not only found very interesting and clever ways to create a peer centered learning experience where the student is taking on the role of teacher but he is administering it in a way to make it work. I think being able to administer theses interesting ideas is just as important as being able to conceptualize them. I cant wait to learn more about what other professors are doing to push this envelope of peer centered learning.
By studying what Bill does I think he has spent an incredible amount of time developing his class. Bill has very thorough instructions and information documents explaining what he wants, what he expects, how the students will be graded, and what it takes to earn an A. And by having his students take on some of the role of the instructor Bill is able to free up time so that he can “provide the necessary structure and directions, supportive and corrective feedback, and evaluation of final product.”
The way Bill’s students take on some of the role of the teacher has a more than one benefit.
It frees up time for Bill to focus on other parts of teaching
It aides the learning process, because to teach something you must have a stronger understanding of the information.
By having the students take on duties like developing each other’s research topics, helping to organize their classmates paper, and working together to collect and critique their classmates web resources, Bill has created a highly interactive, and collaborative class.
My little experience with collaboration and interaction and engaging my classmates in an online environment has to do with the discussion area, where we talk about topics.
I had the idea from reading and experiences in this course to have all teacher comments on all assignments made public in my course, so each student can experience the learning process of every other student. So instead of learning on an individual basis, the learning multiples by every student in the course. But in this respect all my peers in the class I am taking are still on the periphery of my learning process. Bill has found a way to get all the students directly involved in all there peers learning process by having the students work with each during every step of the class.
Bill is really putting together a few ideas to build something big. I have an idea to do a wiki, to work in groups, do independent research, have student lead discussions, and write an essay to summarize all that you learn. I need to synthesize all these ideas into activities that all build on the previous one’s with one final goal in mind, write a culminating essay. instead of using all these ideas I have as independent activities. Bill has done this, and it is wonderful. I am very curious if he did this all in the planning stages, if he started like me with independent activities, or if this course was years in the making.
4
No comments:
Post a Comment